The families owe no apology. The state owes accountability.
|
Listen To This Article Here : 👇🏽🎧
|
The families owe no apology. The state owes accountability.
The MV Barima tragedy concerns more than the conduct of a crew. It tests whether public institutions can answer to the people they serve.
The central issue is not whether their grief makes the government uncomfortable. It is whether the institutions responsible for public safety, oversight, emergency response and recovery have discharged their obligations—and whether there will be meaningful consequences wherever the evidence establishes that they have not.
Nearly four months after the sinking of the MV Barima on July 18, the country should be confronting those questions with urgency. The Commission of Inquiry’s stated scope includes seaworthiness, passenger and cargo operations, crew qualifications and conduct, search and recovery, and regulatory and institutional oversight. Those are not peripheral matters. They describe a chain of responsibility extending well beyond the vessel itself.
Yet the danger remains that public attention will narrow to the people most easily placed in the dock, while the larger machinery of authority continues much as before.
That is not an adequate understanding of accountability.
Responsibility does not stop at the waterline
Three crew members have been charged and remanded. Their guilt or innocence is for the courts to determine, and neither public anger nor political convenience should prejudge those proceedings. Reporting on their most recent court appearance states that they were further remanded, with paper committal proceedings scheduled for November 16.
But criminal proceedings against members of a crew cannot, by themselves, answer questions about the performance of an entire public system.
Who was responsible for ensuring that the vessel could operate safely? What inspections, authorizations and safeguards were required? How were passenger and cargo operations supervised? What information reached the authorities, and what did they do with it? Were emergency arrangements adequate? Were decisions during the response timely and properly coordinated?
These questions do not assume that every official failed. They insist that every relevant level of responsibility be examined.
The government must explain why continued service by those overseeing the relevant institutions is compatible with a credible investigation. Where an official’s conduct or decisions fall within the inquiry’s scope, the public deserves to know whether a conflict-of-interest assessment has been undertaken and whether temporary reassignment or recusal is warranted.
Recusal is not a conviction. Temporary reassignment is not a finding of guilt. Both can protect an investigation, the official concerned and public confidence in the eventual findings.
What cannot be acceptable is an arrangement in which frontline employees face the immediate force of the criminal process while questions about supervisory and institutional responsibility are treated as matters that can wait indefinitely.
Accountability must follow the evidence wherever it leads. It must not lose momentum as it moves upwards.
The disaster has not ended for those living with it
For a family whose loved one remains missing, the tragedy is not a historical event. It is a continuing condition.
It exists in every unanswered call, every uncertain update and every day without the possibility of a funeral. It exists in the terrible suspension between knowing that someone is gone and being unable to bring that person home.
Survivors, too, must not be reduced to a number in an official account. Survival does not settle questions about continuing care, practical assistance or the opportunity to be heard. Their experiences belong at the center of the national response, not at its margins.
No family should have to become publicly confrontational merely to obtain reliable information. No survivor should have to compete with the government’s communications machinery to keep legitimate concerns visible.
A humane response requires more than expressions of sympathy. It requires consistent contact, clearly identified responsibilities, practical support and honest explanations of what can—and cannot—be done.
Where recovery faces serious technical obstacles, those obstacles should be explained plainly. Uncertainty is painful. Uncertainty compounded by poor communication is an avoidable cruelty.
Recovery has brought another death
The death of a diver during operations connected with the salvage effort has added another bereaved family to this disaster’s aftermath. Reporting also records a delay of several days before the authorities publicly disclosed the incident. A subsequent police update, citing a post-mortem examination, gave heart failure as the cause of death.
That medical finding must be reported accurately. A death during an operation does not, by itself, establish negligence. But neither does a stated medical cause remove the need to explain the circumstances, the emergency response and the protections in place for those undertaking hazardous work.
The injury to another worker adds to the need for a clear public account of operational safety.
The people working to recover a vessel or the missing must not become an afterthought in the urgency of the task. Their lives carry the same claim to protection, and their families the same entitlement to information and compassion.
The public deserves to know how personnel are assessed for the work, what emergency arrangements exist, how incidents are reviewed and what changes follow when something goes wrong.
Recovery cannot be judged solely by whether the wreck is eventually raised. It must also be judged by how the operation is conducted and how those doing the work are protected.
Grief does not require political permission
Against this background, attempts to discredit bereaved families because their demands have political implications are morally indefensible.
Of course a demand for accountability has political implications. It concerns the exercise of public power, the management of public institutions and the obligations of the state. That does not make the suffering behind it manufactured.
A family does not lose its right to answers because opposition figures express support. A survivor does not become less credible by criticizing the government. A protest does not become illegitimate merely because its timing is embarrassing.
Political organizations should be challenged when they exploit suffering. But the responsibility for that exploitation belongs to those doing it. Families cannot reasonably be expected to police every expression of solidarity before being permitted to speak.
Nor should they be required to choose between mourning and citizenship.
The expectation that grief must remain private, restrained and politically harmless serves those in authority, not those in pain. It transforms sympathy into a conditional privilege: compassion is available, provided the bereaved do not demand too much.
A democratic society should reject that bargain.
Patience must not become permission
Guyanese should not be blamed for being peaceful or patient. Restraint is not weakness. But patience becomes dangerous when those exercising power begin to treat it as an inexhaustible public resource.
There must be a point at which assurances give way to measurable obligations.
The inquiry should proceed independently, without political interference or predetermined conclusions. Its own counsel has identified institutional oversight and possible systemic shortcomings among the matters requiring examination. That breadth must be preserved in practice, not merely in its terms of reference.
Alongside the inquiry, the government should provide a regular public account of recovery operations, family support, expenditure and immediate safety improvements. It should explain who is responsible for each commitment and how progress will be assessed.
Where information cannot properly be disclosed, the reason should be stated. Where commitments are missed, the failure should be acknowledged. Where evidence establishes misconduct or negligence, consequences should follow.
An inquiry is a means of establishing the truth. It is not a moratorium on governing responsibly.
The state must earn back confidence
The deepest damage from a national tragedy can extend beyond the original loss. It grows when people conclude that institutions are more concerned with defending themselves than examining themselves; that criticism receives a faster response than suffering; that ordinary citizens must explain their anger while officials need not explain their decisions.
That is how a disaster becomes a crisis of legitimacy.
The answer is not to demand quieter families, more accommodating survivors or a more deferential public. It is to demonstrate that public office carries obligations which cannot be delegated downwards when things go wrong.
The families are not responsible for restoring the government’s reputation. Survivors are not responsible for protecting the country’s image. Citizens are not obliged to confuse national loyalty with silence.
The state must earn confidence through disclosure, competence, independent scrutiny and consequences justified by the evidence. Those who have lost the most owe no apology for insisting on that standard.
They have already carried the loss. They must not also be made to carry the burden of shielding power from accountability.
<
p style=”text-align: center;”>
Discover more from 592guardian.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!